Market overview

Across the retail sector, 2011 was undoubtedly a difficult year with harsh winter weather, soaring input prices and downbeat consumer confidence all taking their toll. However, Debenhams performed well against the competition, outperforming the market.

In this section you can place Debenhams performance in context through an independent overview of the UK retail market, review this year’s key market statistics and understand how Debenhams appear well positioned to take advantage of industry trends.

An independent view of the UK retail market from Verdict

Retail in the UK is undergoing a fundamental evolution, one that was inevitable, was accelerated by the recession and is forcing retailers to become much more professional.

Retail growth over the decade up to 2009 was boosted by deflation and low inflation in virtually all non-food sectors. This factor, combined with increases in household disposable income and easy credit, enabled consumers to buy more and more products with very little impact on their overall income. Yet, despite this, retail growth has been slowing; it halved to an average 2.8% in the decade after the millennium and has declined each decade since the 1960s.

Therefore, as a mature sector, with the prospect of an ageing population dampening demand further, retail was inevitably going to become more challenging. Moreover UK consumers have not only cut back on their shopping as confidence has fallen but have also changed their style of shopping.

Rising utility bills, transports costs, higher education costs and actual job losses (or the prospect of them) have all led to consumers having less to spend and less willingness to spend. Rather than rack up more debt they are paying it off, or saving. And when they do buy, price inflation means they buy fewer items and are far more selective about their choices. Therefore if a retailer is not first choice it is unlikely to get any share of spend.

Sectors and retailers dependent on the housing market have suffered the highest number of casualties. Between them, since 2008 DIY, electricals, furniture & floor coverings and homewards have seen a £7.9 billion reduction in consumer expenditure. Sectors that continue to grow are those related to family and personal needs, food & grocery, clothing & footwear and health & beauty, but even in these sectors retailers with a single specialism, like footwear, are under pressure, finding it hard to drive the volumes necessary to cover rising costs.

Retailers therefore need to adapt to a new low growth, inflationary environment. No longer can they rely on opening more space to drive growth, now it is a case of having an efficient multi-channel model that incorporates the optimum range and number of stores in the right locations, combined with e-Retail and m-Commerce operations. Future success will be based on being far better than competitors: growth will come at someone else’s expense, therefore retailers need a strong brand and a distinctive proposition that generates constant customer loyalty. Furthermore, managing operations and costs to generate maximum efficiency and flexibility will be essential.

We at Verdict expect 2012 to be another tough year for retail with little improvement until 2013 (global financial traumas permitting). Whatever the outcome the new normality will be low growth and low volumes with little room for error.

Key market facts 2011

Consumer confidence

Consumer confidence remained negative throughout 2011. After a stable autumn, confidence dropped sharply in January, possibly due to the increase in VAT which was the first of the government’s austerity measures which had a widespread impact on consumers. There was an unprecedented improvement in late spring, in large part due to warm weather, the Royal Wedding and extended bank holiday weekends creating a temporary “feel good” factor. However, this was short-lived and by the end of the year confidence had fallen again.

DEB_consumer

High street sales

High street sales, as measured by the BRC-KPMG Retail Sales Monitor, were volatile during the year on a monthly basis. For the year from September 2010 to August 2011 total sales increased by 0.6% but the monthly range varied from -3.1% in March 2011 to +5.0% in April 2011. On a like-for-like basis, sales fell by 0.8% with a monthly range from -4.2% in March 2011 to an increase of 3.8% in April 2011.

DEB_UK_High_Street_sales

Input prices

2011 was characterised by significant rises in input prices. A poor harvest, crops ruined by bad weather and rising demand from the Chinese domestic market led to a sharp upward movement in the price of cotton. The average month price in 2011 of 167 cents/pound was more than double the previous year (source: National Cotton Council of America “A” index). There was also upward pressure on wool, polyester and other material prices. Labour rates in China rose in line with the government’s plans. On the positive side, freight costs fell during the year as new vessels added capacity at a time when volumes were declining and sterling traded in a reasonably narrow range against the US dollar during the year.

DEB_Monthly_average_cotton_prices

UK clothing selling prices

Higher input prices and concerns over consumer confidence led many retailers to increase prices during 2011. Over the spring summer season, total clothing market selling prices increased by 5.5% (source: Kantar Worldpanel Fashion, 24 weeks market share to 4 September 2011 vs 2010). There was a corresponding volume decline over the period of 3.8%.

DEB_GBP-USD_exchange_rate

Our conclusions

Debenhams performed well in 2011 in a market that was clearly difficult on many levels. Although like-for-like sales fell by 0.3%, they outperformed the market which fell by 0.8%. The impact of higher input prices was managed well and average price increases over the spring summer season of c.4% were lower than the market as a whole which increased by 5.5%. Debenhams is well placed to take advantage of the trends referred to in Verdict’s view of the market with our broad category mix, predominantly in the clothing, footwear and health & beauty sectors, and growing multi‑channel offer.